Sports Media Watch
 

Home arrow Daily Digest arrow Fake News Makes Bad Filler
Fake News Makes Bad Filler Print E-mail
Written by Matt Gaventa   
Monday, 24 October 2005
Despite ESPN’s burgeoning fleet of television stations, they always find ways to fill the air they create. But more and more, SMW has noticed Bristol using cheap devices to fill time, or artificially to create news items that their talking heads can then prolong indefinitely.

Example #1: yesterday’s “special” 90-minute NFL Primetime, extended only because of the absence of Sunday Night Football, which found its extra thirty minutes by using feature segments stolen right from SportsCenter.

Example #2:
SportsCenter’s “must-see” footage of Keyshawn Johnson and Mike Irvin head-to-head, stolen right from NFL Countdown.

The original Irvin/Johnson interview was produced as part of Sunday morning’s NFL Countdown, meant in some small way as a follow-up to Irvin’s repeated announcement that Johnson was not a #1 receiver. And granted, the interview is great TV: Keyshawn makes all sorts of pompous (and possibly delusional) claims, accuses Irvin of messing with “his money,” and suggests that Mike could not have played for Bill Parcells, while Mike looks on with an appropriate degree of skepticism.

On SportsCenter, however, the interview is not treated as journalism – it’s treated as news in and of itself. Instead of just admitting that they’re replaying the interview from earlier in the day, the footage is re-edited into a feature about the interview, as if to suggest that ESPN’s own journalism has made this newsworthy event that merits separate coverage. Please. SMW has no problem with recycling material, and has been known to watch the same SportsCenter several times in a row. But don’t pretend that it’s something that it’s not, and don’t pretend that in-house promos are actually news events.

Speaking of ads masquerading as news, NFL Countdown perennial Daily Show-esque segment “The Mayne Event,” this week targeted the NFL’s most sensational rookie, The Burger King. You’ve seen the ads. And while SMW can’t argue with the comedy, isn’t it unnecessary to devote five minutes of Countdown to making the corporate sponsors happy? Why the free advertising?

The actual stars of yesterday’s NFL action seem to have been the Steelers and Eli Manning’s Giants. Unsurprisingly, Hall of Fame Steelers Quarterback Terry Bradshaw, in his esteemed role as Fox sportswriter, says that Steeltown showed dominance by swatting away the upstart Bengals yesterday afternoon, and, over at CNNSI, Don Banks agrees. Given Green Bay’s collapse yesterday, SMW imagines Peter King had to throw something together not about Brett Favre, and stumbled onto some nice thoughts about Jerome Bettis that make absolutely absurd claims about his legacy.

There was no such equivocation about Eli Manning, and SMW suspects that this week may go down as his coming-out party (if indeed follows the path to stardom that the mediascape paved for him this morning). King appoints himself President of the Eli Manning fan club, even though the editors at CBS Sportsline may have beaten him to it: for much of today, Sportsline’s home page was flanked by two large photos of Manning and prominently advertised video of his interview with Phil Simms from yesterday’s pregame show. Never turning down a party invitation, ESPN joins the fun: Pasquerelli says that Manning is emerging as a full inheritor of his family legacy, and the ever-ridiculous Skip Bayless starts the Montana comparisons, you know, just because we don’t play this game enough.

The big news, though, is still baseball. Ken Rosenthal says the White Sox are getting some help from above, while admitting that they certainly know how to capitalize. George Vecsey says that intervention might be the ghost of Shoeless Joe wreaking havoc with our postseason. In Boston, Shaughnessey gets the best-headline award for “Destiny Changes Her Socks,” wherein he notes that he’s heard all this fate & history talk before. And while King Kauffman agrees that the White Sox are getting a lot of help, he says there’s nothing supernatural about it: it’s just bad umpiring, and it means we need to talk about replay.

There is no shortage of attention to Podsednik’s homerun. Keeping in talk about the supernatural, Jayson Stark says it’s one of those postseason moments that defies explanation. In Chicago, the exuberant Jay Mariotti says it’s just par for the course in such a crazy, offbeat postseason. After all, Podsednik’s not exactly known for his power (nor Mariotti for his objectivity), and he’s the latest and least likely member of an illustrious list.

Flip to the B-side. Nobody wants to be Brad Lidge today. Not Scott Miller at Sportsline. Not Murray Chass, who joins a chorus of noticing that Bobby Jenks fared no better, but just got lucky. Even hometown writer Richard Justice laments for Lidge, who has now given up walk-off postseason home runs in his last two appearances.

Oh, and: nobody watched, talked about, wrote about, or generally gave any attention to Jordan on 60 Minutes, except for Cold Pizza, which indulged in a preposterous conversation about whether MJ could still play in today’s NBA instead of actually engaging the meat of the interview. Is it not actually news? Or do we only care about 60 Minutes features before their airdate? Talk about promotion! 

Tomorrow: ATL v. NYJ, SMW v. TMQ, MLB v. ADA, and any other acronyms that may become important. 

< Prev   Next >