Sports media has kept a watchful eye on the Joe Buck-Troy Aikman-ESPN soap opera, but over the last few weeks, there have been no new developments. In fact, Buck and Aikman sound as strong as ever, reminding viewers each week why they remain the NFL’s best broadcast team.
The silence of the last few weeks stands in stark contrast to the steady drumbeat of chatter and controversy that defined September and October. Just before the second week of the NFL season, Aikman, whose ESPN contract expires after the Super Bowl, appeared on the Sports Media Podcast with Richard Deitsch and expressed disappointment that a deal had not been reached before the season.
That was followed by the reported profanity-laced pregame argument between the two prior to ESPN’s broadcast of Bills-Rams. Then there was Aikman’s appearance on Dallas radio station 96.7, where he suggested this would likely be his last year at ESPN. Earlier this month, Andrew Marchand of The Athletic published an in-depth report on the controversy, describing the partnership as “unraveling.”
The growing rift has many, if not most, sports media observers predicting a change in the “Monday Night Football” booth. Buck has reportedly signed a six-year extension with ESPN, leaving Aikman as the expected odd man out in favor of current Fox analyst Greg Olsen or Peyton Manning.
In recent weeks, the once turbulent waters have seemed to calm a bit. While not altogether surprising — these are professionals, after all — it does raise a question. Had sports media and football fans given up on the Buck-Aikman partnership too soon? Olsen is an excellent young analyst, and Manning has been one of football broadcasting’s most coveted personalities for more than a decade, but neither would be an improvement over Aikman on Monday nights.
In broadcasting, nothing is more important than chemistry, and Buck and Aikman simply have it. For 25 years, they’ve built a rapport, learning each other’s habits and mastering a broadcast that is defined by and rooted in efficiency. Buck’s minimalist style gives his partner more than ample space for analysis while Aikman consistently enhances the broadcast with his candor and conciseness.
There are promising young NFL analysts in the industry right now, but talent is no substitute for time. Buck and Aikman are still at the peak of their powers, showing no signs of slowing down.
To appreciate what the Buck-Aikman partnership means to ESPN, consider how long the network spent searching for the right MNF booth. For more than 15 years, the quality of its lead NFL team trailed those at NBC, CBS and Fox. Mike Tirico and Jon Gruden came closest to giving ESPN a booth that could rival the best, but that collaboration ended when Tirico left for NBC in 2016. Few partnerships in sports television history can match the pedigree of Buck and Aikman.
Assuming all parties can put aside differences, it would be in the best interest of all parties to keep Buck and Aikman together.
Speaking at Sports Business Journal Media Innovators Tuesday, ESPN president Jimmy Pitaro discussed the controversy and praised the longtime broadcasters: “It’s been disappointing, but these guys are professionals, and they’re delivering every week. If you watched them last night, another super high-quality production and telecast, and I’d fully expect that to continue that through the season and through the Super Bowl.”
This could all be wishful thinking. Perhaps too much damage has been done, but if Pitaro, Buck, Aikman and company are committed to doing what’s best for all involved, the 2027-28 season would begin with Troy Aikman sitting in “MNF” the booth alongside Joe Buck.
Plus: Dan Hicks cannot be replaced by one person
NBC Sports paid tribute this weekend to longtime play-by-play voice Dan Hicks, who passed away last week at the age of 64.
Hicks’ sudden passing creates a void that will be difficult for the network to fill. Jason Benetti, who called Saturday’s Boston College-Notre Dame broadcast, makes sense as Hicks’ successor on Notre Dame football, but Hicks’ range and versatility make replacing him across NBC’s sports portfolio a challenge unlikely to be solved by a single broadcaster.
For the last 26 years, he’d been the lead announcer for the network’s golf coverage. He’d been the voice of Olympic swimming since 1996, displaying a unique ability to guide viewers through sports that demand different broadcasting instincts: patience and restraint in golf, urgency and precision in swimming. Hicks could adjust his delivery while keeping his distinctive sound.
During that time, he developed excellent chemistry with swimming analyst Rowdy Gaines, as well as golf analyst Johnny Miller, who retired in 2019. Golf may seem like an easy sport to call, but keeping pace with action across the course can turn an announcer’s earpiece into a jumble of competing voices and instructions. It takes a broadcaster with a special skillset to navigate the chaos.
The games will continue, but they will sound and feel much different. NBC will find capable voices to call them, yet Hicks’ untimely passing reminds us how much a familiar voice can mean — and how precious the trust between an announcer and an audience becomes over time.











