Sports Media Watch
  • Games Today
  • Schedules
    • NFL
      • Arizona Cardinals
      • Atlanta Falcons
      • Baltimore Ravens
      • Buffalo Bills
      • Carolina Panthers
      • Chicago Bears
      • Cleveland Browns
      • Cincinnati Bengals
      • Dallas Cowboys
      • Denver Broncos
      • Detroit Lions
      • Green Bay Packers
      • Houston Texans
      • Indianapolis Colts
      • Jacksonville Jaguars
      • Kansas City Chiefs
      • Las Vegas Raiders
      • Los Angeles Chargers
      • Los Angeles Rams
      • Miami Dolphins
      • Minnesota Vikings
      • New England Patriots
      • New Orleans Saints
      • New York Giants
      • New York Jets
      • Philadelphia Eagles
      • Pittsburgh Steelers
      • San Francisco 49ers
      • Seattle Seahawks
      • Tampa Bay Buccaneers
      • Tennessee Titans
      • Washington Commanders
    • College Sports
      • College Football
      • College Volleyball
      • Men’s College Basketball
      • Women’s College Basketball
      • College Baseball
      • College Softball
      • College Hockey
      • College Field Hockey
      • College Gymnastics
      • College Lacrosse
      • College Wrestling
      • College Soccer
    • NBA
      • NBA Playoffs
      • Atlanta Hawks
      • Boston Celtics
      • Brooklyn Nets
      • Charlotte Hornets
      • Chicago Bulls
      • Cleveland Cavaliers
      • Dallas Mavericks
      • Denver Nuggets
      • Detroit Pistons
      • Golden State Warriors
      • Houston Rockets
      • Indiana Pacers
      • Los Angeles Clippers
      • Los Angeles Lakers
      • Memphis Grizzlies
      • Miami Heat
      • Milwaukee Bucks
      • Minnesota Timberwolves
      • New Orleans Pelicans
      • New York Knicks
      • Oklahoma City Thunder
      • Orlando Magic
      • Philadelphia 76ers
      • Phoenix Suns
      • Portland Trail Blazers
      • Sacramento Kings
      • San Antonio Spurs
      • Toronto Raptors
      • Utah Jazz
      • Washington Wizards
      • NBA G-League
      • FIBA
    • MLB
      • World Baseball Classic
      • Arizona Diamondbacks
      • Athletics
      • Atlanta Braves
      • Baltimore Orioles
      • Boston Red Sox
      • Chicago Cubs
      • Chicago White Sox
      • Cincinnati Reds
      • Cleveland Guardians
      • Colorado Rockies
      • Detroit Tigers
      • Houston Astros
      • Kansas City Royals
      • Los Angeles Angels
      • Los Angeles Dodgers
      • Miami Marlins
      • Milwaukee Brewers
      • Minnesota Twins
      • New York Mets
      • New York Yankees
      • Philadelphia Phillies
      • Pittsburgh Pirates
      • San Diego Padres
      • San Francisco Giants
      • Seattle Mariners
      • St. Louis Cardinals
      • Tampa Bay Rays
      • Texas Rangers
      • Toronto Blue Jays
      • Washington Nationals
    • NHL
      • Stanley Cup Playoffs
      • Anaheim Ducks
      • Boston Bruins
      • Buffalo Sabres
      • Calgary Flames
      • Carolina Hurricanes
      • Chicago Blackhawks
      • Colorado Avalanche
      • Columbus Blue Jackets
      • Dallas Stars
      • Detroit Red Wings
      • Edmonton Oilers
      • Florida Panthers
      • Los Angeles Kings
      • Minnesota Wild
      • Montreal Canadiens
      • Philadelphia Flyers
      • Pittsburgh Penguins
      • Nashville Predators
      • New Jersey Devils
      • New York Islanders
      • New York Rangers
      • Ottawa Senators
      • San Jose Sharks
      • Seattle Kraken
      • St. Louis Blues
      • Tampa Bay Lightning
      • Toronto Maple Leafs
      • Utah Mammoth
      • Vancouver Canucks
      • Vegas Golden Knights
      • Washington Capitals
      • Winnipeg Jets
      • IIHF
    • WNBA
      • Atlanta Dream
      • Chicago Sky
      • Connecticut Sun
      • Dallas Wings
      • Golden State Valkyries
      • Indiana Fever
      • Las Vegas Aces
      • Los Angeles Sparks
      • Minnesota Lynx
      • New York Liberty
      • Phoenix Mercury
      • Portland Fire
      • Seattle Storm
      • Toronto Tempo
      • Washington Mystics
    • Tennis
      • Australian Open
      • Indian Wells
      • Miami Open
      • French Open
      • Wimbledon
      • US Open
    • Golf
      • PGA Tour
      • LPGA
      • LIV Golf
      • TGL
      • The Masters
      • PGA Championship
      • U.S. Open
      • U.S. Women’s Open
      • British Open
      • Ryder Cup
    • Club Soccer
      • Premier League
      • MLS
      • NWSL
      • UEFA Champions League
      • Serie A
      • Bundesliga
      • LaLiga
    • International Soccer
      • FIFA World Cup
      • FIFA Club World Cup
      • Concacaf Gold Cup
      • UEFA Women’s Euros
    • Olympic Sports
      • Olympic Games
      • US Olympic Trials
      • Figure skating
      • Elite gymnastics
      • Track & Field
      • Cycling
    • Motorsports
      • NASCAR
      • Formula 1
      • IndyCar
      • NHRA
    • CFL
    • UFL
    • UFC
    • PBA Tour
    • Little League
    • Pro Lacrosse
    • Pro Volleyball
    • Athletes Unlimited
    • The Basketball Tournament
    • Unrivaled
    • PWHL
    • BIG3
  • Ratings
    • Ratings Tracker
    • Ratings Predictions
    • College Football TV Ratings
  • Features
    • Monday Musings
    • The Needle
    • On the Air
    • On Location
  • News
    • By sport
      • NFL
      • College football
      • NBA
      • WNBA
      • MLB
      • NHL
      • Soccer
      • Golf
      • Motorsports
      • Horse racing
      • Tennis
      • College basketball
      • Other College Sports
      • Combat sports
      • Olympics
      • Other sports
    • By network
      • RSNs
      • ESPN
      • ABC
      • FOX
      • NBC
      • CBS
      • TNT Sports
      • Amazon
      • Netflix
      • Apple
      • Golf Channel
      • NFL Network
      • MLB Network
      • Nexstar
      • Scripps
      • Univision
    • By topic
      • Rights Deals
      • Broadcasters
  • Podcast
  • Contact
No Result
View All Result
Sports Media Watch
Today's Games
  • NFL Schedule
  • CFB Schedule
  • All Schedules
  • CFB Ratings
  • Ratings Tracker
  • Ratings News
  • Podcast

Home › Linear Media › Disney › ESPN › Decisions, Decisions

Decisions, Decisions

by Jon Lewis
16 years ago
Share
Share
  • Share on X (Twitter)
  • Share on Bluesky
  • Share on Threads
  • Share via Email
  • Copy Link
0

ESPN is the big bad wolf of sports, frequently vilified by virtually every corner of sports — its colleagues in the media, the fans, even some athletes. Some criticism is fair, and some goes overboard.

Take, for example, the wild, frantic furor over the network’s decision to air LeBron James‘ The Decision — a no-brainer that many outlets slamming the network would have made in a heartbeat. The articles tearing ESPN to shreds by and large make the argument that this is a new low for the network, one that either wipes away all of its previous accomplishments or reinforces that its previous glory is long gone.

All ESPN did was get the LeBron James news straight from the horse’s mouth and attract its third-largest non-NFL audience of the past twenty years in the process. Apparently, the correct decision would have been to let some other outlet get the James news first and have about seven million fewer people watch a previously-scheduled World Cup Special instead.

Did ESPN destroy its credibility by airing the James special? That depends on whether one believes the credibility of a decades-old television network/news organization can be shattered by a pretty harmless one-hour special. Great journalism it wasn’t, but ESPN didn’t exactly blow up a truck, here. And is credibility really that fragile? Did airing The Decision suddenly render irrelevant John Barr‘s recent report on human trafficking in South Africa?

Some may say that the very act of allowing James to ‘hijack’ ESPN’s airwaves for his own personal gain destroyed its credibility. But James did not ‘hijack’ anything. ESPN did not air this special to benefit (or kowtow to) LeBron James, they aired it because the subject of arguably the biggest story in sports was willing to end years of speculation on their airwaves. James was less hijacker than invited guest — and ESPN was not alone in welcoming him into their home, as nearly 10 million viewers watched the show.

ESPN may not have had control over the initial interview with James, conducted by former employee Jim Gray, but that took up less than half of the one-hour show. After the Gray portion was over, the network had its own Michael Wilbon ask James questions that would not have otherwise been asked if, say, ‘The Decision’ had been announced in some sort of press release — for example, when Wilbon asked James about fans in Cleveland burning his jerseys.

The fact is, ESPN got the story before anyone else, and they attracted a massive (for cable) audience. They did so by allowing LeBron James one hour of airtime, most of which was no different from a typical ESPN studio show.

Fanhouse.com media writer Milton Kent said this about The Decision: “You cannot hand over an hour of time to someone that you cover. You cannot let that person dictate where the proceeds from that hour will go, and you cannot let that person make the call on who will interview him.”

Perhaps this is the most important, although highly unpopular question: why not? How exactly has ESPN changed by giving James airtime, allowing him to give the proceeds to charity and letting Jim Gray interview him? Has this somehow destroyed the ability of the network to do good journalism? Did it drain Bob Ley and others of their abilities?

Does it set a precedent? Not really. If Carmelo Anthony wants to do a similar special next year, odds are that ESPN would say no — even if it hadn’t been criticized for the James special. Far fewer people would care about Anthony’s decision.

So how did airing The Decision affect ESPN? Are viewers offended? If they were, they would not have tuned in to begin with — after all, the arrangements for the special were well-publicized beforehand. Sure, it hurt the perception of the network among sports media critics, but they never really held the network in such high esteem to begin with.

The truth is, credibility is fragile, since it exists in the eye of the beholder — for some, Fox News is the single most trustworthy news organization, for others its MSNBC. CNN apparently believes Eliot Spitzer is credible enough to host a one-hour talk show, others might disagree. And for every individual who believes The Decision to be the death-knell of ESPN as a respectable news outlet, there are those who believe it is far from a big deal.

The decision to air The Decision was not a tragedy, a defining moment or even a mistake. It was far from the greatest moment in the history of sports journalism, but it was also far from the worst.

Previous Post

It Takes Two: Afternoon MLB on FOX Hits 2.0 For First Time Since May

Next Post

The Ratings Game

Jon Lewis

Jon Lewis has been covering the sports media industry on a daily basis since 2006 as the founder and main writer of Sports Media Watch. You can contact him here or on the social media websites X (Twitter) or Bluesky.

Related

The YouTube logo pictured in Los Angeles. Courtesy: Derek Futterman, Sports Media Watch

YouTube joins list of companies passing on World Cup bid

by Jon Lewis
2 hours ago
2

What once promised to be a robust market for FIFA World Cup rights has dwindled to just three confirmed...

San Francisco 49ers running back Christian McCaffrey (23) carries the ball during an NFL football game against the Dallas Cowboys in Arlington, Texas, Sunday, Nov. 15, 2026. (AP Photo/Matt Patterson)

NFL viewership remains on the high end through Week 10

by Jon Lewis
7 hours ago
1

NFL viewership remains on the high side after a Week 10 that included multiple highs across multiple windows. NFL...

The FIFA World Cup 2026 logo pictured alongside the Fox Sports logo. Courtesy: Derek Futterman, Sports Media Watch

Fox reportedly pairing with Univision for joint World Cup bid

by Jon Lewis
23 hours ago
8

Rights to the next FIFA World Cup will come down to Fox versus the streamers. Fox Corporation has paired...

The FIFA logo pictured on a blimp at Fanatics Fest. Courtesy: Derek Futterman, Sports Media Watch

News: FIFA hydration breaks, NFL alt-casts, ESPN subscribers and more

by Derek Futterman
1 day ago
6

FIFA has reportedly included a hydration break provision in documents for World Cup rights; NFL EVP/chief media officer Hans...

SMW Podcast

Remembering Dan Hicks, plus a conversation with John Kosner and Ed Desser
0:000:00
Sports Ratings Tracker
logoOther NASCAR Series
The NASCAR Truck Series averaged 540,000 viewers on Fox Sports during the 2026 season, up 12% from last year, with races on FS1 up 21%. The season finale at Homestead-Miami averaged a 0.25 and 462,000 on FS1, up a tick in ratings and 2% in viewership from last year’s Phoenix finale (0.24, 455K). Read more
logoWednesday NBA
Wednesday’s Cavaliers-Knicks NBA regular season game averaged 1.9 million viewers on ESPN, up 44% from Magic-Knicks last year (1.3M), followed by Warriors-Rockets at 1.7 million — up 14% from Lakers-Thunder a year ago (1.5M). Read more
logoChampions Classic and other college hoops
Tuesday’s Michigan State-Duke Champions Classic men’s college basketball game averaged 1.6 million viewers on ESPN, up 5% from Kentucky-Michigan State last year, and the top audience for the early game of the annual doubleheader since 2022 (Kentucky-Michigan State: 2.03M). Read more
logoSuperMotocross
The SMX World Championship Series, including the indoor AMA Supercross Championship and outdoor Pro Motocross Championship, averaged 614,000 viewers on NBC across a Nielsen-measured linear audience and streaming viewership tracked by Adobe Analytics — up 17% from last year.
logoNielsen updates NBC NFL viewership
Nielsen has reprocessed the viewership for NBC’s four NFL games from Week 1-3 of the season. The Patriots-Seahawks Kickoff Game has been updated to 25.2 million, up from an originally-reported 25.1 million. The Week 1 Cowboys-Giants “Sunday Night Football” game has been updated to 25.82 million, up from 25.66 million. Colts-Chiefs the following week has been updated to 24.43 million, up from 24.29 million. Finally, Rams-Broncos in Week 3 has been updated to 20.96 million, up from 20.77 million.
logoWNBA Semis
Last Wednesday’s Liberty-Dream WNBA semifinal Game 2 averaged 1.4 million viewers on ESPN, down from Mercury-Lynx in the comparable window last year (1.5M). Last year’s games took place earlier in the calendar and did not face the MLB Postseason. Read more
logoALDS
The MLB American League Division Series was averaging 3.4 million viewers on TNT Sports through Thursday, up 2% from last year’s ALDS on Fox Sports. Last Thursday’s Guardians-White Sox Game 4 averaged 3.8 million opposite NFL “Thursday Night Football,” on par with Brewers-Cubs in the same window last year. Read more
Add SMW as a trusted source in Google News.

Latest Posts

YouTube joins list of companies passing on World Cup bid

NFL viewership remains on the high end through Week 10

Fox reportedly pairing with Univision for joint World Cup bid

News: FIFA hydration breaks, NFL alt-casts, ESPN subscribers and more

Disney, Apple, also reportedly out of World Cup bidding

Skydance reportedly passes on World Cup rights

Sports Media Watch

About • Contact • Report an Error • Privacy

© 2026 Jon Lewis, Sports Media Watch

No Result
View All Result
  • Games Today
  • Schedules
    • NFL
      • Arizona Cardinals
      • Atlanta Falcons
      • Baltimore Ravens
      • Buffalo Bills
      • Carolina Panthers
      • Chicago Bears
      • Cleveland Browns
      • Cincinnati Bengals
      • Dallas Cowboys
      • Denver Broncos
      • Detroit Lions
      • Green Bay Packers
      • Houston Texans
      • Indianapolis Colts
      • Jacksonville Jaguars
      • Kansas City Chiefs
      • Las Vegas Raiders
      • Los Angeles Chargers
      • Los Angeles Rams
      • Miami Dolphins
      • Minnesota Vikings
      • New England Patriots
      • New Orleans Saints
      • New York Giants
      • New York Jets
      • Philadelphia Eagles
      • Pittsburgh Steelers
      • San Francisco 49ers
      • Seattle Seahawks
      • Tampa Bay Buccaneers
      • Tennessee Titans
      • Washington Commanders
    • College Sports
      • College Football
      • College Volleyball
      • Men’s College Basketball
      • Women’s College Basketball
      • College Baseball
      • College Softball
      • College Hockey
      • College Field Hockey
      • College Gymnastics
      • College Lacrosse
      • College Wrestling
      • College Soccer
    • NBA
      • NBA Playoffs
      • Atlanta Hawks
      • Boston Celtics
      • Brooklyn Nets
      • Charlotte Hornets
      • Chicago Bulls
      • Cleveland Cavaliers
      • Dallas Mavericks
      • Denver Nuggets
      • Detroit Pistons
      • Golden State Warriors
      • Houston Rockets
      • Indiana Pacers
      • Los Angeles Clippers
      • Los Angeles Lakers
      • Memphis Grizzlies
      • Miami Heat
      • Milwaukee Bucks
      • Minnesota Timberwolves
      • New Orleans Pelicans
      • New York Knicks
      • Oklahoma City Thunder
      • Orlando Magic
      • Philadelphia 76ers
      • Phoenix Suns
      • Portland Trail Blazers
      • Sacramento Kings
      • San Antonio Spurs
      • Toronto Raptors
      • Utah Jazz
      • Washington Wizards
      • NBA G-League
      • FIBA
    • MLB
      • World Baseball Classic
      • Arizona Diamondbacks
      • Athletics
      • Atlanta Braves
      • Baltimore Orioles
      • Boston Red Sox
      • Chicago Cubs
      • Chicago White Sox
      • Cincinnati Reds
      • Cleveland Guardians
      • Colorado Rockies
      • Detroit Tigers
      • Houston Astros
      • Kansas City Royals
      • Los Angeles Angels
      • Los Angeles Dodgers
      • Miami Marlins
      • Milwaukee Brewers
      • Minnesota Twins
      • New York Mets
      • New York Yankees
      • Philadelphia Phillies
      • Pittsburgh Pirates
      • San Diego Padres
      • San Francisco Giants
      • Seattle Mariners
      • St. Louis Cardinals
      • Tampa Bay Rays
      • Texas Rangers
      • Toronto Blue Jays
      • Washington Nationals
    • NHL
      • Stanley Cup Playoffs
      • Anaheim Ducks
      • Boston Bruins
      • Buffalo Sabres
      • Calgary Flames
      • Carolina Hurricanes
      • Chicago Blackhawks
      • Colorado Avalanche
      • Columbus Blue Jackets
      • Dallas Stars
      • Detroit Red Wings
      • Edmonton Oilers
      • Florida Panthers
      • Los Angeles Kings
      • Minnesota Wild
      • Montreal Canadiens
      • Philadelphia Flyers
      • Pittsburgh Penguins
      • Nashville Predators
      • New Jersey Devils
      • New York Islanders
      • New York Rangers
      • Ottawa Senators
      • San Jose Sharks
      • Seattle Kraken
      • St. Louis Blues
      • Tampa Bay Lightning
      • Toronto Maple Leafs
      • Utah Mammoth
      • Vancouver Canucks
      • Vegas Golden Knights
      • Washington Capitals
      • Winnipeg Jets
      • IIHF
    • WNBA
      • Atlanta Dream
      • Chicago Sky
      • Connecticut Sun
      • Dallas Wings
      • Golden State Valkyries
      • Indiana Fever
      • Las Vegas Aces
      • Los Angeles Sparks
      • Minnesota Lynx
      • New York Liberty
      • Phoenix Mercury
      • Portland Fire
      • Seattle Storm
      • Toronto Tempo
      • Washington Mystics
    • Tennis
      • Australian Open
      • Indian Wells
      • Miami Open
      • French Open
      • Wimbledon
      • US Open
    • Golf
      • PGA Tour
      • LPGA
      • LIV Golf
      • TGL
      • The Masters
      • PGA Championship
      • U.S. Open
      • U.S. Women’s Open
      • British Open
      • Ryder Cup
    • Club Soccer
      • Premier League
      • MLS
      • NWSL
      • UEFA Champions League
      • Serie A
      • Bundesliga
      • LaLiga
    • International Soccer
      • FIFA World Cup
      • FIFA Club World Cup
      • Concacaf Gold Cup
      • UEFA Women’s Euros
    • Olympic Sports
      • Olympic Games
      • US Olympic Trials
      • Figure skating
      • Elite gymnastics
      • Track & Field
      • Cycling
    • Motorsports
      • NASCAR
      • Formula 1
      • IndyCar
      • NHRA
    • CFL
    • UFL
    • UFC
    • PBA Tour
    • Little League
    • Pro Lacrosse
    • Pro Volleyball
    • Athletes Unlimited
    • The Basketball Tournament
    • Unrivaled
    • PWHL
    • BIG3
  • Ratings
    • Ratings Tracker
    • Ratings Predictions
    • College Football TV Ratings
  • Features
    • Monday Musings
    • The Needle
    • On the Air
    • On Location
  • News
    • By sport
      • NFL
      • College football
      • NBA
      • WNBA
      • MLB
      • NHL
      • Soccer
      • Golf
      • Motorsports
      • Horse racing
      • Tennis
      • College basketball
      • Other College Sports
      • Combat sports
      • Olympics
      • Other sports
    • By network
      • RSNs
      • ESPN
      • ABC
      • FOX
      • NBC
      • CBS
      • TNT Sports
      • Amazon
      • Netflix
      • Apple
      • Golf Channel
      • NFL Network
      • MLB Network
      • Nexstar
      • Scripps
      • Univision
    • By topic
      • Rights Deals
      • Broadcasters
  • Podcast
  • Contact

© 2026 Jon Lewis, Sports Media Watch